The short answer
EKRA (18 U.S.C. § 220) makes it a federal crime to pay or receive anything of value for referring patients to a clinical treatment facility, recovery home or lab, even when private insurance pays. Pay-per-lead and pay-per-admit deals do not fit its exceptions. A 2025 appeals court ruling said percentage pay is not automatically illegal, but the safest model for a rehab is still a flat fee for marketing work.
On this page 7 sections
What EKRA is
The Eliminating Kickbacks in Recovery Act became law in 2018 as part of the federal response to the opioid crisis. Before it, the federal Anti-Kickback Statute mostly covered government-paid care. Patient brokers in the treatment industry worked around it by targeting people with private insurance. EKRA closed that gap.
What the law actually says
Under 18 U.S.C. § 220(a), for services covered by a health care benefit program, it is a crime to knowingly and willfully:
- Solicit or receive any remuneration in return for referring a patient to a recovery home, clinical treatment facility or laboratory; or
- Pay or offer any remuneration to induce a referral to one of those, or in exchange for someone using their services.
Remuneration includes any kickback, bribe or rebate, “directly or indirectly, overtly or covertly, in cash or in kind.” The penalty is a fine of up to $200,000, imprisonment of up to 10 years, or both, for each occurrence.
Who it covers
- Clinical treatment facility: a non-hospital medical setting that provides detox, residential treatment or rehabilitation for substance use under a state license or certification.
- Recovery home: a shared living environment that is, or claims to be, free from alcohol and illicit drugs and focused on peer support.
- Laboratory: clinical labs, which is where most early EKRA cases came from.
“Health care benefit program” is defined in 18 U.S.C. § 24(b) as any public or private plan or contract affecting commerce that provides medical benefits, so private insurance is included, not just Medicare and Medicaid.
The exceptions, and why marketing deals rarely fit
EKRA lists eight exceptions in § 220(b). The one most marketing arrangements try to use is the employee and contractor exception. It protects payments to an employee or independent contractor only when the pay does not depend on, or vary with, the number of individuals referred, the number of tests or procedures, or the amounts billed or received.
That rules out the protection for:
- Pay per lead, call or form fill that is sold as a referral.
- Pay per admission or “per head.”
- A percentage of revenue collected from referred patients.
- Bonuses for admissions staff tied to the number of admits.
Falling outside an exception does not automatically make a deal illegal. It means you lose the safe ground and the deal is judged on its facts, with prison on the table.
What courts have said about marketer pay
On July 11, 2025, the Ninth Circuit decided United States v. Schena, a published opinion and one of the first appeals court rulings on EKRA. As summarized by Holland & Knight, the court held that:
- EKRA reaches payments to marketers and other middlemen who deal only with providers, not just people who deal with patients directly.
- Percentage or commission pay is not a violation by itself. It becomes one when paired with undue influence over referrals, such as false or fraudulent statements.
The same panel issued a companion decision, S&G Labs Hawaii v. Graves. Both cases involved laboratories, both bind only federal courts in the Ninth Circuit, and other circuits may read the law differently. Treat them as a sign of how courts think, not as permission.
Do not read Schena as “commissions are fine.” The court still found EKRA covers marketers, and state laws such as Florida’s Patient Brokering Act can apply even where EKRA does not. LegitScript also disqualifies centers tied to lead generators.
Common rehab marketing deals, ranked by risk
| Arrangement | Risk | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Flat monthly fee for SEO, ads management, website work | Lower | Pay does not vary with referrals; you own the accounts and the calls. |
| Ad spend paid directly to Google or Meta | Lower | You pay the platform for ad placement, not a person for referrals. |
| Salaried in-house marketing or admissions staff | Lower | Fits the employee exception if pay does not vary with admits. |
| Pay per call from a third-party lead seller | High | Pay rises with each referral; often tied to hotlines LegitScript disqualifies. |
| Pay per admission, or a share of collections | Highest | Pay is tied directly to patients and billing. |
| Paying recovery homes, interventionists or patients for referrals | Highest | Classic brokering; recovery homes are named in the statute. |
We work on flat, custom quoted fees and never charge per admission or per patient.
Talk to us about compliant growthA simple EKRA check for any deal
- Does anyone get paid more when more patients come to us? If yes, stop and call counsel.
- Is the payment for work we can describe (design, ad management, content), at fair market value?
- Do calls and forms come straight to our own team, under our own name?
- Would we be comfortable showing this contract to LegitScript and to a prosecutor?
For a list of warning signs in agency pitches, see patient brokering red flags.
FAQ
Does EKRA apply if we only accept private insurance?
Yes. EKRA applies to services covered by a health care benefit program, which includes private insurance plans. That is the gap it was written to close.
Is it legal to pay Google for ads?
Paying an ad platform for ad placement is not paying someone for a referral. Google and Meta do require LegitScript certification before you can run addiction treatment ads in the US.
What is the penalty for an EKRA violation?
Up to $200,000 in fines, up to 10 years in prison, or both, for each occurrence.
Did the Ninth Circuit make commissions legal?
No. In United States v. Schena (2025) it said percentage pay is not automatically illegal, but becomes illegal when combined with undue influence such as false statements. The ruling binds only courts in the Ninth Circuit.
Sources4 sources
This guide is general information, not legal advice. EKRA case law is still developing; talk to a healthcare attorney before signing any marketing contract. Checked November 2026.