Free audit
Compliance

Patient Brokering Red Flags: How to Vet a Rehab Agency

Patient brokering is a crime under federal EKRA and state laws. Learn the red flags in rehab marketing agency pitches and the questions to ask before you sign.

The short answer

Patient brokering means paying or receiving anything of value in exchange for sending a patient to a treatment provider. It is a federal crime under EKRA and a crime under state laws such as Florida’s. When you hire a marketing agency, walk away if it prices by the admit or “head”, runs its own hotline or directory, uses other centers’ names, or offers to cover patients’ travel or insurance.

On this page 7 sections
  1. What patient brokering is
  2. The laws that apply
  3. Why the agency you hire matters
  4. Red flags in an agency pitch
  5. Questions to ask before you sign
  6. What ethical marketing looks like instead
  7. FAQ

What patient brokering is

Patient brokering is trading patients for money. A broker finds people seeking addiction treatment, often through hotlines, directories or recovery residences, and steers them to whichever facility pays. The patient is treated as inventory, and many end up in programs that do not fit their needs.

The law does not care whether the payment is called a commission, a marketing fee, a bonus or a “lead”. What matters is whether something of value is exchanged for a referral.

The laws that apply

Federal: EKRA

The Eliminating Kickbacks in Recovery Act (18 U.S.C. § 220) makes it a crime to knowingly and willfully solicit or receive any remuneration for referring a patient to a recovery home, clinical treatment facility or laboratory, or to pay or offer remuneration to induce such a referral. It covers services paid by any health care benefit program, which includes private insurance. The penalty is a fine of up to $200,000, up to 10 years in prison, or both, for each occurrence. Our EKRA guide for marketers covers it in depth.

Florida: the Patient Brokering Act

Florida’s § 817.505 bans offering, paying, soliciting or receiving any commission, bonus, rebate, kickback or split fee for patient referrals, and also bans aiding or advising such a deal. A violation is a third-degree felony with a $50,000 fine. It becomes a second-degree felony with a $100,000 fine when 10 to 19 patients are involved, and a first-degree felony with a $500,000 fine at 20 or more.

California: SB 1228

California’s SB 1228, signed in September 2018, bars licensed and certified addiction treatment programs, and people who own or work for them, from giving or receiving anything of value for referrals. Violations can cost a facility its license.

Other states have their own rules, and the federal Anti-Kickback Statute applies when government programs pay for care. Check with a healthcare attorney for your states.

Why the agency you hire matters

Treatment centers rarely set out to broker patients. The risk usually arrives inside a marketing contract. Florida’s law covers anyone who aids or participates in brokering, and EKRA covers both sides of the payment. If your agency’s model is brokering, you are part of it.

It also ends your ads. LegitScript’s certification standards prohibit co-ownership of, or any formal or informal affiliation with, lead generators. Sponsoring or answering a lead generator’s hotline counts as informal affiliation and can lead to immediate denial. Without LegitScript, you cannot advertise addiction treatment on Google or Meta.

Red flags in an agency pitch

What they sayWhy it is a problem
“You only pay per admission” or “per head”Payment that rises with each patient referred is the core of brokering. It does not fit EKRA’s exception for pay that does not vary with referrals.
“We have our own call center and hotline network”Generic hotlines that route callers to the highest bidder are the classic brokering setup, and LegitScript treats sponsoring them as affiliation.
“We own directory sites that send you leads”Directories that sell calls to treatment centers are lead generators. LegitScript disqualifies affiliation with them.
“We bid on competitors’ names in your ads”LegitScript’s advertising standard says ads must not use third-party business names, and families searching for another center are being misled.
“We can cover patients’ flights, rent or insurance”LegitScript says paying for travel, rent or premiums is problematic and such applicants are generally ineligible. In many states it is also illegal.
“Guaranteed admits”No honest agency controls who needs treatment. Guarantees usually mean bought or routed patients.
“We’ll send you the calls; you don’t need the recordings”If you cannot see where calls came from, you cannot prove they were not brokered.

We never charge per admission or per patient. Our fees are flat and quoted up front for the work itself.

Read our marketing standards

Questions to ask before you sign

  1. How are you paid? The answer should be a flat fee or retainer for work done, not anything tied to the number of calls, leads, admits or billing.
  2. Who owns the ad accounts, phone numbers and website? You should, in your business name.
  3. Do you own or work with any hotlines, directories or call centers that serve other treatment centers? A yes needs a very clear explanation.
  4. Will you sign a business associate agreement? If the agency handles call recordings or form data with patient information, it should.
  5. Will every ad and landing page name our center and our real address? Unbranded “find a rehab” pages are a warning sign.
  6. Can we see call recordings and source data for every lead? Transparency protects you.
  7. Will you help keep our LegitScript certification? A good agency knows the standards and works within them.

What ethical marketing looks like instead

Ethical agencies are paid for the work: building your website, running your Google Business Profile and ads, writing content, and setting up tracking. The calls come to your own admissions team, under your own name, and you decide who is a clinical fit. That is slower than buying patients, and it is the only model that keeps your license, your certification and your reputation.

FAQ

Is patient brokering illegal everywhere in the US?

Federal EKRA applies nationwide to referrals to recovery homes, clinical treatment facilities and laboratories paid by public or private insurance. Many states, including Florida and California, also have their own laws.

Is paying a marketing agency a flat monthly fee legal?

A flat fee for marketing services that does not change with the number of patients referred is the common, lower-risk model. Have a healthcare attorney review any contract.

Can we pay our own admissions staff bonuses per admit?

EKRA’s employee exception covers pay that does not depend on the number of individuals referred. Per-admit bonuses fall outside it, so ask counsel before using them.

What should we do if we already have a per-admit contract?

Stop new referrals under it and speak with a healthcare attorney about how to exit and what to disclose.

Want this done for your center?

Get a free audit of your website, ads, local listings and tracking. No obligation.

No spam. We only use this to prepare your audit. See our privacy policy.

Get a free growth audit